It’s clear that disabled author Olivia Muscat knows just how frustrating and inaccurate some portrayals of disability (and especially blindness) can be. Equally as clear is her passion for telling a more accurate narrative, with all the real-life frustrations and unexpected aspects that can come with it. It’s that own-voices approach that makes her new novel Annie and Maeve are Definitely Not Friends so engaging, and so refreshing. This sassy and relatable middle grade novel for readers eight and over is a tale of belonging, identity, and (despite what the girls might have you believe) friendship that will warm your heart.
Annie and Maeve are Definitely Not Friends is the tale of two girls – Annie and Maeve, naturally – who are both blind. Despite being different in almost every other way, everyone assumes that their shared disability means they have to be the best of friends. Right? Wrong. Alongside dealing with all the many other annoying assumptions that come with being blind, the pair have to navigate this weird not-friendship and all the usual trials of fifth grade – from camp and the school talent contest to annoying boys and family drama. And maybe, somewhere along the way, they’ll come to realise that being friends might not be so bad after all.
Both Annie and Maeve are complex and messy characters, with problems pretty much everyone can relate to. Though the novel engages with their struggles against discrimination in a kid-friendly manner, it certainly doesn’t sand them down. Disabled readers will be glad to see a story that really reflects their experiences, while those who are not will find it introduces them to a new point of view – one that’s based in real, lived experiences.
It’s also fast paced, with a casual and sassy voice that makes for light and funny reading, keeping even younger kids engaged right up until the end. It balances real and raw experiences with a great sense of humour and uplifting moments.
With the novel including a number of teaching notes (accessible via the Fremantle Press website), Annie and Maeve are Definitely Not Friends is a great pick as a learning and discussion book, opening up able-bodied kids to new perspectives and reminding disabled kids that they are not alone. But this book doesn’t need to be educational to be good – it stands on its own as a great read. It’s engaging and full off complicated issues, yet with a happy ending, a blend that all kids are sure to love.
FOUR AND A HALF STARS (OUT OF FIVE)
Annie and Maeve are Definitely Not Friends is available now from Fremantle Press. Get it now from your local bookstore HERE.
Header image supplied by Fremantle Press.
