I’m going to admit something here: despite the fact it’s been doing the rounds, I haven’t read The Housemaid by Freida McFadden yet. Instead, I’ve been reading her latest novel, The Witch. And coming to understand just why she’s become so popular lately.
Though the book has its share of flaws, The Witch was a fun read, with plenty of mystique. Along with a premise to separate it from all the rest, it also delivers an ending that satisfies. McFadden excels at stories that are quick and snappy, dark yet not depressing.
In an unusual turn, The Witch is told through two viewpoints. The first is Caroline, a young woman from 1692 who, despite her kindness, is declared a witch. The other is Julia, a young woman who in the modern day resides in the same house Caroline once lived in – and which is said to be haunted by her ghost. While her relatives argue over the sale of the home, and strange happenings plague each night, Julia dives into a past which seems to be rapidly catching up with her.
Julia’s story is where the majority of the plot happens; it’s where she investigates the mysteries of the house while living with a great-aunt who disproves of her efforts and a grandmother who isn’t always certain of who she is. Unfortunately, it’s also not as interesting as Caroline’s story of witch hunts. While it does have its moments, including an exhilarating twist and satisfying ending, it is not particularly unique and is at times rather basic and on-the-nose with its exposition. Some of her ‘investigations’ feel slow and have little point. Despite the moments of humour and her efforts to connect with a grandmother succumbing to dementia, there’s simply not enough to make Julia and her story stand out.
Caroline’s sections, on the other hand, are more exciting. Despite its relative shortness, knowing her inevitable end makes her story tragically compelling – and allows for a few unexpected twists. Subtle differences in the prose and dialogue also immerse you in this different era.
Ultimately and despite my reservations, The Witch held my attention. The main plot moved slowly, but had moments of tension and a gripping conclusion despite the epilogue feeling a little lacklustre. If you want something thrilling but not too scary this Spooky Season, it’s worth checking out.
THREE STARS (OUT OF FIVE)
The Witch by Freida McFadden is out now from Poisoned Pen Press. Find a copy at your local bookstore HERE.
Header image provided by Poisoned Pen Press.
