Film Review: 99 Homes (USA, 2015)

Once named “the director of the decade” from the late, iconic film critic Roger Ebert (who, in turn, has this film dedicated to him), Ramin Bahrani’s new film 99 Homes is a self-described “humanist thriller”, which takes us into the realities of the American housing crisis, out of which tragedy and corruption has emerged. Set in Florida, we meet Dennis Nash (Andrew Garfield), a down on his luck construction worker (and all around handy man) whose family (including a rather perplexed Laura Dern, who plays his Mother) is forced out of their home by flash real estate broker Rick Carver (Michael Shannon) after it’s repossessed by the bank.

The scene of the house repossession, which helps set off the film, is an immediately striking one. The camera moves freely through the house as Garfield and Dern deal with a stressful, confusing and dehumanising experience, that has stemmed from their own lack of understanding of the process. Which, seemingly, has been made complicated and confusing for that very reason. As it turns out, people tend to get very rich off the bad situation others may find themselves in. You immediately empathise with the family, and detest Shannon, with Bahrani (also serving as editor) and his cinematographer Bobby Bukowski doing an incredible job of throwing the audience into the deep end. What follows is a series of events that sees Garfield’s character end up working for Shannon, going on to evict people from their homes just as Rick Carver did to him just weeks before.

Dennis does this, at first, to save his family home and get them out from living in a motel. But it’s not long before he gets caught up in the corruption that has led Rick into living the financially comfortable life anyone would desire. The question then becomes, does he let himself get completely sucked into this world of no return, or can he escape and redeem himself before it’s too late?

It’s a thrilling and engrossing storyline that is buoyed by fantastic performances – especially from our two leads – a stellar script from our director with Amir Naderi, a gripping score from Antony Partos and Matteo Zingales, as well as some daring and excellent cinematography. Bahrani keeps the audience asking “what would I do in this situation?” throughout, ultimately leaving you to answer the question of who is the real villain in all this. Though detestable at the start, it’s hard not to come to respect – even root for – Carver, much as he wins over Nash.

What’s really remarkable (and, perhaps terrifying) about the film, is its inspiration from reality. In our interview with Bahrani, he says almost all of the plot points on corruption, abuse of the system and mistreatment of the everyday family, are based on actual events he witnessed or researched while in Florida. And though Florida serves as the film’s home, it was filmed in New Orleans and really could represent anywhere in the USA that the housing crisis has impacted. Much as I said in my Sydney Film Festival review of Going Clear, it’s horrifying to imagine these are realities that the government is not only allowing to happen, but actually a part of; local and state governments benefiting from the crisis. As Shannon’s character alludes to, it’s created a Kill or Be Killed world, where real estate brokers are forced into doing things they never signed up to do.

Andrew Garfield and Michael Shannon shine in the film, and both are deserving of award nominations for their turns. It’s a gripping film, as much a thriller as it is a drama, full of social commentary (which equates it at times to a horror film knowing these things are actually happening), with a mesmerising score, excellent direction and impressive cinematography. 99 Homes is a film everyone should see.


99 Homes was reviewed earlier this year at the Sydney Film Festival. The film is released this Thursday, November 19th. You can read and listen to our interview with the director HERE.


This content has recently been ported from its original home on The Iris and may have formatting errors – images may not be showing up, or duplicated, and galleries may not be working. We are slowly fixing these issue. If you spot any major malfunctions making it impossible to read the content, however, please let us know at editor AT

Larry Heath

Founding Editor and Publisher of the AU review. Currently based in Toronto, Canada. You can follow him on Twitter @larry_heath or on Instagram @larryheath.